All models

BMW M5

GermanNationwide US · 173 listings · 38 great deals · updated 2026-11-11
Under $90K
63 cars
Cheapest
$48,277
Average
$73,200
Great deals
38
Verify CARFAX
147 flagged

Deal breakdown

159 priced vs. fair value · click to filter · how?
Great Deal 38Good Deal 21Fair Price 46High 33Overpriced 21
Median price $103,158Median miles 13,203
★ Best deal right now
$64,761
2021 Base · 47,567 mi
$29,201 under fair value (fair $93,962)
Fair range $86,623–$111,427 · vs 123 comparable listings
Cheaper than 91% of comparable listings

Price vs. mileage

each dot is a listing · line = market trend · dots below the line are better value
$42K$71K$99K$128K$156K013k25k38k50kMileage2019 Base — $48,277 · 45,000 mi2019 Base — $50,790 · 44,267 mi2019 Base — $53,395 · 36,554 mi2019 Base — $56,519 · 40,243 mi2019 Base — $58,989 · 39,333 mi2025 Base — $59,288 · 11,370 mi2020 Base — $59,332 · 31,133 mi2019 Sedan 4D — $59,999 · 24,267 mi2021 M5 — $59,999 · 40,000 mi · Great Deal2019 Competition — $60,372 · 39,457 mi · Great Deal2020 Base — $62,574 · 38,135 mi2020 Base — $63,995 · 29,551 mi2019 Base — $64,650 · 44,625 mi · Great Deal2021 Base — $64,761 · 47,567 mi · Great Deal2019 Competition — $65,971 · 31,387 mi · Good Deal2020 Competition — $65,997 · 37,487 mi · Great Deal2020 Competition — $66,291 · 48,506 mi · Great Deal2021 Base — $66,400 · 48,926 mi · Great Deal2019 Competition — $67,995 · 43,707 mi · Fair Price2020 Competition — $68,438 · 43,957 mi · Fair Price2019 Competition — $68,999 · 49,000 mi · Fair Price2020 Competition — $69,489 · 31,987 mi · Good Deal2022 Base — $69,962 · 29,956 mi · Great Deal2020 Competition — $69,991 · 39,773 mi · Fair Price2019 Competition — $69,995 · 26,397 mi · Good Deal2021 Base — $70,000 · 48,160 mi · Great Deal2023 Base — $70,985 · 40,705 mi · Great Deal2021 Base — $71,495 · 31,575 mi · Great Deal2019 Competition — $71,995 · 24,184 mi · Fair Price2019 Competition — $72,500 · 28,701 mi · Fair Price2021 Competition — $73,495 · 48,096 mi · High2023 Base — $75,151 · 36,224 mi · Great Deal2022 Base — $75,999 · 27,327 mi · Great Deal2023 Base — $77,463 · 33,950 mi · Great Deal2020 Base — $77,666 · 27,145 mi · Great Deal2023 Competition — $78,495 · 48,051 mi · High2022 w/ EXECUTIVE PKG, DRIVER ASSISTANCE PRO PKG — $78,500 · 23,728 mi · Good Deal2022 Base — $78,900 · 29,783 mi · Great Deal2021 Base — $79,165 · 29,956 mi · Great Deal2022 Base — $79,299 · 23,728 mi · Great Deal2023 Base — $79,594 · 44,759 mi · Great Deal2022 Base — $79,898 · 26,410 mi · Great Deal2022 Base — $79,949 · 9,470 mi · Great Deal2021 Base — $79,979 · 18,456 mi · Great Deal2022 Competition — $79,990 · 35,499 mi · High2022 Competition — $79,991 · 30,001 mi · High2022 Base — $79,993 · 30,375 mi · Great Deal2023 M5 — $79,998 · 25,053 mi · Good Deal2023 Competition — $80,994 · 25,625 mi · Overpriced2023 Base — $81,800 · 32,681 mi · Good Deal2023 Base — $81,995 · 20,478 mi · Great Deal2023 Base — $82,550 · 29,882 mi · Great Deal2023 Base — $82,695 · 39,240 mi · Great Deal2023 Base — $83,298 · 40,546 mi · Great Deal2023 Base — $83,500 · 12,537 mi · Great Deal2023 Base — $84,183 · 39,663 mi · Great Deal2023 Base — $84,649 · 13,203 mi · Great Deal2023 M5 — $84,998 · 32,295 mi · Good Deal2023 Base — $86,214 · 16,394 mi · Great Deal2019 Competition — $86,999 · 23,859 mi · High2023 Base — $87,349 · 21,374 mi · Great Deal2023 Base — $87,387 · 10,897 mi · Great Deal2022 Competition — $89,999 · 40,721 mi · Overpriced2023 Base — $90,000 · 25,000 mi · Good Deal2025 M5 — $94,995 · 20,720 mi · Good Deal2023 COMPETITION — $94,995 · 18,653 mi · High2023 COMPETITION-CARBON CERAMICS! — $94,995 · 10,611 mi · Good Deal2022 Competition — $95,990 · 21,258 mi · Overpriced2023 COMPETITION-EXECUTIVE PACKAGE! — $96,995 · 16,646 mi · Fair Price2025 M5 — $97,500 · 27,835 mi · Fair Price2025 Base — $97,688 · 16,859 mi · Great Deal2025 Base — $98,170 · 14,111 mi · Good Deal2022 Base — $98,497 · 15,120 mi · Fair Price2025 M5 — $98,995 · 19,184 mi · Fair Price2026 Base — $99,888 · 23,411 mi · Good Deal2025 Base — $99,999 · 8,927 mi · Good Deal2025 Base — $100,171 · 22,439 mi · Good Deal2026 Base — $100,573 · 8,968 mi · Great Deal2025 Base — $100,693 · 21,667 mi · Good Deal2025 Base — $101,500 · 15,210 mi · Good Deal2025 Base — $102,061 · 12,222 mi · Good Deal2025 Base — $102,197 · 6,924 mi · Great Deal2026 Base — $102,382 · 16,542 mi · Good Deal2026 Base — $102,559 · 25,330 mi · Fair Price2025 Base — $102,737 · 3,087 mi · Great Deal2025 Base — $102,989 · 15,761 mi · Good Deal2026 Base — $103,158 · 10,230 mi · Good Deal2025 Base — $104,327 · 17,338 mi · Fair Price2023 COMPETITION — $104,995 · 4,783 mi · High2025 Base — $105,750 · 7,266 mi · Fair Price2025 Base — $106,379 · 5,084 mi · Fair Price2026 Base — $106,687 · 1,442 mi · Great Deal2026 Base — $106,700 · 14,762 mi · Fair Price2025 Base — $107,401 · 4,594 mi · Fair Price2026 Base — $107,798 · 14,150 mi · Fair Price2026 Base — $107,890 · 16,539 mi · Fair Price2025 Base — $108,218 · 21,642 mi · Fair Price2025 Base — $108,338 · 24,664 mi · High2026 Base — $108,394 · 9,761 mi · Fair Price2026 Base — $108,502 · 7,941 mi · Fair Price2025 Base — $108,643 · 9,386 mi · Fair Price2025 Base — $108,906 · 15,637 mi · Fair Price2026 Base — $108,997 · 6,961 mi · Fair Price2026 Base — $109,581 · 6,272 mi · Fair Price2025 Base — $109,800 · 5,300 mi · Fair Price2026 Base — $109,985 · 4,219 mi · Fair Price2025 Base — $109,995 · 7,542 mi · Fair Price2025 Base — $110,294 · 8,924 mi · Fair Price2026 Base — $110,412 · 10,455 mi · Fair Price2026 Base — $110,491 · 3,542 mi · Fair Price2026 Base — $110,652 · 13,110 mi · Fair Price2025 CS — $110,700 · 12,261 mi · Fair Price2026 Base — $110,797 · 3,051 mi · Fair Price2025 Base — $110,998 · 11,430 mi · Fair Price2026 Base — $111,498 · 9,380 mi · Fair Price2026 Base — $111,710 · 5,541 mi · Fair Price2025 Base — $111,800 · 8,416 mi · Fair Price2026 Base — $111,815 · 7,570 mi · Fair Price2025 Base — $111,959 · 14,960 mi · High2025 Touring — $111,970 · 5,976 mi · Fair Price2025 Touring — $111,998 · 7,145 mi · Fair Price2025 Base — $112,417 · 4,300 mi · Fair Price2026 Base — $112,503 · 7,116 mi · Fair Price2025 Base — $112,737 · 6,052 mi · High2026 Base — $112,797 · 8,453 mi · High2025 Base — $112,995 · 5,378 mi · High2026 M5 — $113,578 · 4,072 mi · High2026 Base — $113,625 · 1,835 mi · High2025 Base — $113,722 · 16,924 mi · High2025 Base — $113,942 · 10,011 mi · High2025 Base — $114,100 · 12,374 mi · High2025 Base — $114,849 · 7,998 mi · Overpriced2026 Base — $114,991 · 5,277 mi · High2021 Competition — $114,999 · 12,019 mi2026 Base — $115,225 · 966 mi · High2026 Base — $115,346 · 4,600 mi · Overpriced2025 Base — $115,695 · 1,893 mi · High2026 Base — $116,003 · 2,913 mi · Overpriced2025 Base — $116,222 · 6,593 mi · Overpriced2025 Base — $116,710 · 8,775 mi · Overpriced2026 Base — $117,497 · 8,000 mi · High2026 Base — $117,975 · 12,350 mi · High2025 Base — $118,214 · 5,034 mi · Overpriced2026 Base — $118,494 · 1,029 mi · High2025 Touring w/ EXECUTIVE PKG, M DRIVERS PKG, M DRIVE PRO, ACC — $118,500 · 4,149 mi · Good Deal2025 Base — $118,942 · 7,911 mi · Overpriced2025 Base — $119,299 · 4,149 mi · Overpriced2026 Base — $119,392 · 6,092 mi · Overpriced2025 Touring — $119,995 · 7,600 mi · Fair Price2025 Touring — $119,995 · 1,295 mi · Fair Price2027 Base — $119,999 · 4,523 mi · Overpriced2027 Base — $120,072 · 6,705 mi · Overpriced2026 Base — $120,407 · 10,936 mi · High2026 Base — $120,575 · 88 mi · High2026 Base — $120,688 · 7,202 mi · Overpriced2026 Base — $120,879 · 8,989 mi · Overpriced2026 Base — $120,898 · 2,777 mi · Overpriced2025 Base — $120,975 · 16,921 mi · Overpriced2026 Base — $120,990 · 8,329 mi · High2026 Base — $121,285 · 6,683 mi · Overpriced2027 Base — $121,684 · 7,168 mi · Overpriced2027 Base — $121,997 · 912 mi · Overpriced2026 Touring — $124,991 · 1,025 mi · Fair Price2025 -FULL SATIN PPF-OVER $30K MODS! — $124,995 · 10,167 mi · High2026 Frozen Deep Grey — $125,000 · 7,000 mi · High2027 M5 — $128,899 · 348 mi · High2026 Call or Text Scott Long @ 814-242-8404 — $132,635 · 26 mi · High2026 Individual Daytona Purple Metallic! Akrapovic Exhaust! Like — $133,813 · 2,057 mi · High2025 Touring-$40K MODS-SATIN PP-BBS WHEELS-EXHAUST! — $134,995 · 12,155 mi · High2026 Touring-FULL PPF-$20K MODS! — $137,995 · 2,442 mi · High2022 CS — $149,495 · 9,110 mi2026 Base — $149,822 · 4,074 mi2025 Custom Sedan Carbon, Executive & Driving Assist Pro Pkgs Carbon — $150,212 · 17,571 mi
CompareExport Excel63 cars
–
–
Trim
Body15% have this
Colour16% have this
Transmission16% have this
Source
Deal
Price▲YearTrimBodyMileageAccident / Title HistoryDealerLocationSource
2019 Base
$48,277
2019Base45,000 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXElmhurst FordBensenville, ILCars.comView
2019 Base
$50,790
2019Base44,267 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXJ & S AutohausEwing, NJCars.comView
2019 Base
$53,395
2019Base36,554 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXGreat Deal High Demand—Cars.comView
2019 Base
$56,519
2019Base40,243 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXNoblesville ImportsNoblesville, INCars.comView
2019 Base
$58,989
2019Base39,333 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXKearns Motor Car Co.Johnson Creek, WICars.comView
2025 Base
$59,288
2025Base11,370 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXGreat Deal Range Score | Excellent—Cars.comView
2020 Base
$59,332
listed 73+ days
2020Base31,133 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXZeigler Honda of RacineMt Pleasant, WICars.comView
2019 Sedan 4D
$59,999
2019Sedan 4DSedan24,267 miNo accidents/damage reported Clean title—eBayCars.comView
2021 M5
$59,999
listed 73+ days
Great deal — $27,384 (31%) below the $87,383 fair price, cheaper than 88% of 8 comparable listings.$27,384 under
2021M540,000 miNo accidents/damage reported Clean title—eBayCars.comView
2019 Competition
$60,372
↓ $906 this week
Great deal — $10,780 (15%) below the $71,152 fair price, cheaper than 96% of 23 comparable listings.$10,780 under
2019Competition39,457 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXMercedes-Benz of North OlmstedNorth Olmsted, OHCars.comView
2020 Base
$62,574
↓ $713 this week
2020Base38,135 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXBMW of RocklandRockland, MACars.comView
2020 Base
$63,995
2020Base29,551 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXStream Auto Outlet IslipIslip, NYCars.comView
2019 Base
$64,650
Great deal — $27,226 (30%) below the $91,876 fair price, cheaper than 92% of 123 comparable listings.$27,226 under
2019Base44,625 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXAutoBayBurlington, NJCars.comView
2021 Base
$64,761
Great deal — $29,201 (31%) below the $93,962 fair price, cheaper than 91% of 123 comparable listings.$29,201 under
2021Base47,567 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXCastle SubaruPortage, INCars.comView
2019 Competition
$65,971
Good deal — $5,811 (8%) below the $71,782 fair price, cheaper than 91% and lower mileage than 52% of 23 comparable listings.$5,811 under
2019Competition31,387 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXSchomp BMWHighlands Ranch, COCars.comView
2020 Competition
$65,997
Great deal — $5,354 (8%) below the $71,351 fair price, cheaper than 87% of 23 comparable listings.$5,354 under
2020Competition37,487 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXAUTOVEND USA LLCPompano Beach, FLCars.comView
2020 Competition
$66,291
Great deal — $2,192 (3%) below the $68,483 fair price, cheaper than 83% of 23 comparable listings.$2,192 under
2020Competition48,506 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXCars2Us FairfaxFairfax, VACars.comView
2021 Base
$66,400
Great deal — $27,181 (29%) below the $93,581 fair price, cheaper than 90% of 123 comparable listings.$27,181 under
2021Base48,926 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXMercedes-Benz of EastonColumbus, OHCars.comView
2019 Competition
$67,995
Fair price — $1,202 (2%) below the $69,197 fair price, cheaper than 78% of 23 comparable listings.$1,202 under
2019Competition43,707 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXCitywide Automotive North LLCAmenia, NYCars.comView
2020 Competition
$68,438
Fair price — $1,161 (2%) below the $69,599 fair price, cheaper than 74% of 23 comparable listings.$1,161 under
2020Competition43,957 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXPerformance Luxury SportMarysville, OHCars.comView
2019 Competition
$68,999
Fair price — $735 (1%) above the $68,264 fair price, cheaper than 70% of 23 comparable listings.
2019Competition49,000 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXAV AutosAurora, COCars.comView
2020 Competition
$69,489
Good deal — $2,700 (4%) below the $72,189 fair price, cheaper than 65% of 23 comparable listings.$2,700 under
2020Competition31,987 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXAutoNation Lincoln Orange ParkJacksonville, FLCars.comView
2022 Base
$69,962
listed 121+ days
Great deal — $27,328 (28%) below the $97,290 fair price, cheaper than 89% of 123 comparable listings.$27,328 under
2022Base29,956 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXLynnes HyundaiBloomfield, NJCars.comView
2020 Competition
$69,991
Fair price — $769 (1%) below the $70,760 fair price, cheaper than 61% of 23 comparable listings.$769 under
2020Competition39,773 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXAuto Boom LLCScottsdale, AZCars.comView
2019 Competition
$69,995NEW
Good deal — $3,457 (5%) below the $73,452 fair price, cheaper than 57% and lower mileage than 65% of 23 comparable listings.$3,457 under
2019CompetitionSedan26,397 miNo accidents/damage reported Clean title—eBayCars.comView
2021 Base
$70,000
Great deal — $23,183 (25%) below the $93,183 fair price, cheaper than 89% of 123 comparable listings.$23,183 under
2021Base48,160 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXPrivate seller: DavidSheboygan Falls, WICars.comView
2023 Base
$70,985
listed 114+ days
Great deal — $25,474 (26%) below the $96,459 fair price, cheaper than 88% of 123 comparable listings.$25,474 under
2023Base40,705 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXLorenzo Buick GMCMiami, FLCars.comView
2021 Base
$71,495
↓ $500 this week
Great deal — $25,299 (26%) below the $96,794 fair price, cheaper than 87% of 123 comparable listings.$25,299 under
2021Base31,575 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXGood Deal High Demand—Cars.comView
2019 Competition
$71,995
Fair price — $372 (1%) above the $71,623 fair price, cheaper than 52% and lower mileage than 74% of 23 comparable listings.
2019Competition24,184 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXPresidential Auto Sales & ServiceDelray Beach, FLCars.comView
2019 Competition
$72,500
Fair price — priced right around the $72,492 fair-price estimate, lower mileage than 61% of 23 comparable listings.
2019Competition28,701 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXPower Motors EastMassapequa Park, NYCars.comView
2021 Competition
$73,495
↓ $500 this week
Priced high — $3,864 (6%) above the $69,631 fair price for 23 comparable listings.$3,864 over
2021Competition48,096 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXPremier Auto LoungePinellas Park, FLCars.comView
2023 Base
$75,151
Great deal — $23,673 (24%) below the $98,824 fair price, cheaper than 86% of 123 comparable listings.$23,673 under
2023Base36,224 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXKarma WestfieldWestfield, NJCars.comView
2022 Base
$75,999
Great deal — $21,843 (22%) below the $97,842 fair price, cheaper than 85% of 123 comparable listings.$21,843 under
2022Base27,327 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXThe Platinum Collection LLCDelray Beach, FLCars.comView
2023 Base
$77,463
listed 121+ days
Great deal — $21,893 (22%) below the $99,356 fair price, cheaper than 85% of 123 comparable listings.$21,893 under
2023Base33,950 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXBommarito ToyotaHazelwood, MOCars.comView
2020 Base
$77,666
↓ $111 this weeklisted 73+ days
Great deal — $18,760 (19%) below the $96,426 fair price, cheaper than 84% of 123 comparable listings.$18,760 under
2020Base27,145 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXYosh Motors of SomervilleSomerville, NJCars.comView
2023 Competition
$78,495
listed 73+ days
Priced high — $3,684 (5%) above the $74,811 fair price for 23 comparable listings.$3,684 over
2023CompetitionSedan48,051 miNo accidents/damage reported Clean title—eBayCars.comView
2022 w/ EXECUTIVE PKG, DRIVER ASSISTANCE PRO PKG
$78,500
listed 73+ days
Good deal — $4,317 (5%) below the $82,817 fair price for 1 comparable listing. (Few comparables — lower confidence.)$4,317 under
2022w/ EXECUTIVE PKG, DRIVER ASSISTANCE PRO PKGSedan23,728 miNo accidents/damage reported Clean title—eBayView
2022 Base
$78,900
Great deal — $18,143 (19%) below the $97,043 fair price, cheaper than 83% of 123 comparable listings.$18,143 under
2022Base29,783 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXPower Motors EastMassapequa Park, NYCars.comView
2021 Base
$79,165
Great deal — $17,029 (18%) below the $96,194 fair price, cheaper than 82% of 123 comparable listings.$17,029 under
2021Base29,956 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXGood Deal High Demand—Cars.comView
2022 Base
$79,299
Great deal — $19,629 (20%) below the $98,928 fair price, cheaper than 81% of 123 comparable listings.$19,629 under
2022Base23,728 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXAuto Collection of MurfreesboroMurfreesboro, TNCars.comView
2023 Base
$79,594
↓ $199 this weeklisted 73+ days
Great deal — $17,698 (18%) below the $97,292 fair price, cheaper than 80% of 123 comparable listings.$17,698 under
2023Base44,759 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXGravity Autos HollywoodHollywood, FLCars.comView
2022 Base
$79,898
listed 114+ days
Great deal — $18,800 (19%) below the $98,698 fair price, cheaper than 80% of 123 comparable listings.$18,800 under
2022Base26,410 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXRocky Mountain Eurosport ParkerParker, COCars.comView
2022 Base
$79,949
listed 73+ days
Great deal — $20,976 (21%) below the $100,925 fair price, cheaper than 79% and lower mileage than 56% of 123 comparable listings.$20,976 under
2022Base9,470 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXThe Platinum Collection LLCDelray Beach, FLCars.comView
2021 Base
$79,979
listed 73+ days
Great deal — $20,968 (21%) below the $100,947 fair price, cheaper than 78% of 123 comparable listings.$20,968 under
2021BaseSedan18,456 miNo accidents/damage reported Clean title—eBayView
2022 Competition
$79,990
Priced high — $5,953 (8%) above the $74,037 fair price for 23 comparable listings.$5,953 over
2022Competition35,499 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXD & C Motor CompanyPortland, ORCars.comView
2022 Competition
$79,991
Priced high — $5,319 (7%) above the $74,672 fair price, lower mileage than 57% of 23 comparable listings.$5,319 over
2022Competition30,001 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXRPM GarageDallas, TXCars.comView
2022 Base
$79,993NEW
Great deal — $17,772 (18%) below the $97,765 fair price, cheaper than 77% of 123 comparable listings.$17,772 under
2022Base30,375 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXVan Horn Hyundai of Fond du LacFond du Lac, WICars.comView
2023 M5
$79,998
listed 73+ days
Good deal — $15,999 (17%) below the $95,997 fair price, cheaper than 75% of 8 comparable listings.$15,999 under
2023M525,053 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXCarMax Boynton BeachBoynton Beach, FLCars.comView
2023 Competition
$80,994
Overpriced — $2,780 (4%) above the $78,214 fair price, lower mileage than 70% of 23 comparable listings.$2,780 over
2023Competition25,625 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXAuto Buying ServiceFairfax, VACars.comView
2023 Base
$81,800
Good deal — $18,549 (18%) below the $100,349 fair price, cheaper than 76% of 123 comparable listings.$18,549 under
2023Base32,681 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXUltimo Motors North ShoreNorthbrook, ILCars.comView
2023 Base
$81,995
listed 73+ days
Great deal — $21,040 (20%) below the $103,035 fair price, cheaper than 76% of 123 comparable listings.$21,040 under
2023Base20,478 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXSouth Shore NissanAmityville, NYCars.comView
2023 Base
$82,550
↓ $300 this week
Great deal — $17,488 (17%) below the $100,038 fair price, cheaper than 75% of 123 comparable listings.$17,488 under
2023Base29,882 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXPorsche MinneapolisGolden Valley, MNCars.comView
2023 Base
$82,695
listed 73+ days
Great deal — $15,571 (16%) below the $98,266 fair price, cheaper than 74% of 123 comparable listings.$15,571 under
2023Base39,240 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXCrazy CarsHillside, NJCars.comView
2023 Base
$83,298
Great deal — $15,249 (15%) below the $98,547 fair price, cheaper than 73% of 123 comparable listings.$15,249 under
2023Base40,546 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXKarma WestfieldWestfield, NJCars.comView
2023 Base
$83,500
Great deal — $19,089 (19%) below the $102,589 fair price, cheaper than 72% of 123 comparable listings.$19,089 under
2023Base12,537 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXKoons Sterling FordSterling, VACars.comView
2023 Base
$84,183
Great deal — $14,757 (15%) below the $98,940 fair price, cheaper than 72% of 123 comparable listings.$14,757 under
2023Base39,663 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXJaguar Land Rover of Fort MyersFort Myers, FLCars.comView
2023 Base
$84,649
Great deal — $19,569 (19%) below the $104,218 fair price, cheaper than 71% of 123 comparable listings.$19,569 under
2023Base13,203 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXWalser Subaru St. PaulSt. Paul, MNCars.comView
2023 M5
$84,998
Good deal — $6,948 (8%) below the $91,946 fair price, cheaper than 62% of 8 comparable listings.$6,948 under
2023M532,295 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXCarMax Palm DesertPalm Desert, CACars.comView
2023 Base
$86,214
listed 73+ days
Great deal — $16,602 (16%) below the $102,816 fair price, cheaper than 70% of 123 comparable listings.$16,602 under
2023Base16,394 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXCar Place DallasAddison, TXCars.comView
2019 Competition
$86,999
Priced high — $14,083 (19%) above the $72,916 fair price, lower mileage than 78% of 23 comparable listings.$14,083 over
2019Competition23,859 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXBrooklyn Auto SalesStaten Island, NYCars.comView
2023 Base
$87,349
Great deal — $16,259 (16%) below the $103,608 fair price, cheaper than 69% of 123 comparable listings.$16,259 under
2023Base21,374 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXDC MotorsHampstead, NHCars.comView
2023 Base
$87,387
Great deal — $17,540 (17%) below the $104,927 fair price, cheaper than 68% and lower mileage than 52% of 123 comparable listings.$17,540 under
2023Base10,897 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXMercedes-Benz of Bowling GreenBowling Green, KYCars.comView
2022 Competition
$89,999
Overpriced — $16,677 (23%) above the $73,322 fair price for 23 comparable listings.$16,677 over
2022Competition40,721 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXBrooklyn Auto SalesStaten Island, NYCars.comView

Highlighted rows = accident history not shown by the listing; confirm via CARFAX before purchase. CarGurus prices may include dealer fees, so a duplicate car is priced from Cars.com / Autotrader where available.

Market price trend

as of 2026-11-11
$103K▲ 10.9% over 18 wks
Median asking price of listed BMW M5 inventory over time — reflects what's for sale, not a single car's value.

How the BMW M5 market moves

modeled from 173 live listings
−5.8%/yrlost to age, miles held equal
−$6K/10k mivalue cost of every 10,000 miles
$103Ktypical asking today
Estimated value vs. mileage · higher-mileage cars sit lower on the curve

Trend forecast: ≈ −$12K over the next 12 months · at ~10k mi/yr, depreciation only — excludes market swings

Market: German asking prices are down 1.4% over the last 20 weeks, holding model, mileage and age constant. · a separate signal from depreciation, not added to it

What each trim is worth · vs. Base, same age & miles
  • Base131baseline
  • Competition23+$12K
  • Touring5+$7K

More German cars

Browse all →
Audi S3169 listings · 49 greatBMW M8176 listings · 45 greatMercedes-AMG C43171 listings · 42 greatMercedes-AMG E 53146 listings · 41 greatAudi S4179 listings · 40 greatAudi S5165 listings · 38 great