All models

BMW M5

GermanNationwide US · 86 listings · 26 great deals · updated 2026-08-04
Under $90K
35 cars
Cheapest
$54,900
Average
$73,025
Great deals
26
Verify CARFAX
84 flagged

Deal breakdown

78 priced vs. fair value · click to filter · how?
Great Deal 26Good Deal 9Fair Price 15High 10Overpriced 18
Median price $97,174Median miles 15,956
★ Best deal right now
$64,777
2022 Base · 48,294 mi
$29,936 under fair value (fair $94,713)
Fair range $93,292–$106,577 · vs 70 comparable listings
Cheaper than 91% of comparable listings

Price vs. mileage

each dot is a listing · line = market trend · dots below the line are better value
$51K$71K$90K$110K$130K013k25k38k50kMileage2022 CS — $54,900 · 29,000 mi2020 Competition — $54,900 · 29,800 mi2019 Base — $57,655 · 40,956 mi2019 M5 — $59,617 · 40,177 mi · Great Deal2022 Base — $59,900 · 34,000 mi2019 Base — $59,990 · 48,136 mi2019 Base — $61,577 · 39,541 mi2019 Competition — $62,445 · 46,554 mi · Great Deal2019 Competition — $62,522 · 35,760 mi · Great Deal2020 Base — $63,599 · 42,701 mi2022 Base — $64,777 · 48,294 mi · Great Deal2023 Base — $70,700 · 42,914 mi · Great Deal2019 Base — $70,975 · 43,162 mi · Great Deal2021 Base — $72,677 · 45,782 mi · Great Deal2022 Base — $73,134 · 29,956 mi · Great Deal2021 Base — $73,792 · 39,809 mi · Great Deal2023 Base — $74,880 · 40,705 mi · Great Deal2022 Base — $74,993 · 27,327 mi · Great Deal2021 Base — $74,999 · 31,148 mi · Great Deal2020 Competition — $75,373 · 25,557 mi · Good Deal2022 Base — $75,889 · 40,779 mi · Great Deal2023 Competition — $76,246 · 41,911 mi · Good Deal2023 Base — $76,888 · 35,820 mi · Great Deal2021 Competition — $81,388 · 6,930 mi · Great Deal2023 Base — $82,895 · 39,240 mi · Great Deal2022 Base — $82,950 · 23,728 mi · Good Deal2023 Base — $83,139 · 33,950 mi · Great Deal2023 Base — $83,200 · 30,817 mi · Great Deal2023 Base — $83,580 · 30,158 mi · Great Deal2022 Base — $83,890 · 26,410 mi · Great Deal2023 Base — $83,995 · 25,183 mi · Great Deal2023 Base — $84,280 · 26,554 mi · Good Deal2022 Base — $84,495 · 24,656 mi · Good Deal2023 Base — $84,777 · 32,486 mi · Great Deal2023 Base — $84,845 · 31,751 mi · Great Deal2023 Competition — $90,477 · 25,687 mi · High2023 Base — $90,484 · 35,962 mi · Great Deal2023 Competition — $90,895 · 40,601 mi · High2022 Competition — $92,373 · 14,653 mi · High2023 Base — $92,942 · 17,799 mi · Good Deal2023 Base — $93,213 · 22,240 mi · Good Deal2025 Base — $95,795 · 21,763 mi · Good Deal2023 Base — $96,348 · 13,203 mi · Great Deal2023 Competition — $97,999 · 15,804 mi · High2023 Base — $98,270 · 15,282 mi · Great Deal2023 Competition — $98,523 · 43,652 mi · Overpriced2023 Base — $99,000 · 20,700 mi · Fair Price2025 Base — $107,522 · 10,777 mi · Fair Price2025 Base — $107,537 · 7,963 mi · Fair Price2025 Base — $107,914 · 3,603 mi · Fair Price2025 Base — $107,985 · 6,894 mi · Fair Price2026 Base — $108,373 · 16,107 mi · Fair Price2025 Base — $108,441 · 8,630 mi · Fair Price2026 Base — $108,750 · 8,237 mi · Fair Price2025 Base — $108,785 · 4,200 mi · Fair Price2025 Base — $108,987 · 5,511 mi · Fair Price2026 Base — $109,248 · 12,163 mi · Fair Price2027 M5 — $111,222 · 813 mi · Good Deal2026 Base — $111,995 · 4,981 mi · Fair Price2026 Base — $112,010 · 9,499 mi · Fair Price2026 Base — $112,950 · 8,985 mi · Fair Price2025 Base — $113,220 · 4,129 mi · Overpriced2025 Base — $113,342 · 6,439 mi · High2026 Base — $113,667 · 3,498 mi · Fair Price2025 Base — $113,970 · 9,358 mi · High2026 Base — $117,164 · 2,907 mi · Overpriced2025 Base — $117,270 · 11,220 mi · Overpriced2025 Base — $117,509 · 10,292 mi · Overpriced2025 Base — $118,349 · 7,998 mi · Overpriced2026 Base — $118,396 · 5,983 mi · Overpriced2026 Base — $118,569 · 1,029 mi · Overpriced2025 Base — $118,838 · 3,113 mi · High2025 Base — $118,998 · 10,725 mi · Overpriced2026 Base — $119,000 · 2,446 mi · High2026 Base — $119,308 · 1,733 mi · High2026 Base — $119,754 · 9,805 mi · High2026 Base — $119,788 · 7,880 mi · Overpriced2026 Base — $123,778 · 295 mi · Overpriced2025 Base — $124,275 · 4,524 mi · Overpriced2026 Base — $124,796 · 1,767 mi · Overpriced2025 Base — $124,987 · 7,745 mi · Overpriced2022 Competition — $124,999 · 11,696 mi2026 Base — $125,164 · 1,007 mi · Overpriced2026 Base — $125,624 · 4,789 mi · Overpriced2026 Base — $125,898 · 2,777 mi · Overpriced2025 Touring — $125,998 · 7,145 mi · Overpriced
CompareExport Excel35 cars
–
–
Trim
Source
Deal
Price▲YearTrimBodyMileageAccident / Title HistoryDealerLocationSource
$54,900NEW
2022CS29,000 miACCIDENT/damage REPORTEDBidgodrive.com—AutotraderView
2020 Competition
$54,900
2020Competition29,800 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXHigh DemandHollywood, FLCars.comView
2019 Base
$57,655
listed 48+ days
2019Base40,956 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXNissan of Orange ParkJacksonville, FLCars.comView
2019 M5
$59,617
Great deal — $5,675 (9%) below the $65,292 fair price, cheaper than 50% of 2 comparable listings. (Few comparables — lower confidence.)$5,675 under
2019M540,177 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXHighline Auto SalesWillowbrook, ILCars.comView
2022 Base
$59,900
2022Base34,000 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXPrivate seller: AliDallas, TXCars.comView
2019 Base
$59,990
listed 48+ days
2019Base48,136 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXD & C Motor CompanyPortland, ORCars.comView
2019 Base
$61,577
listed 69+ days
2019Base39,541 miNo accidents/damage reported (CPO)Luxury Sport AutoTigard, ORCars.comView
2019 Competition
$62,445
Great deal — $15,513 (20%) below the $77,958 fair price, cheaper than 83% of 12 comparable listings.$15,513 under
2019Competition46,554 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXR21 MotorsportsNW Canal Fulton, OHCars.comView
2019 Competition
$62,522
↓ $27 this week
Great deal — $18,165 (23%) below the $80,687 fair price, cheaper than 75% of 12 comparable listings.$18,165 under
2019Competition35,760 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXBonita Beach MitsubishiBonita Springs, FLCars.comView
2020 Base
$63,599
2020Base42,701 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXHigh Demand—Cars.comView
2022 Base
$64,777NEW
Great deal — $29,936 (32%) below the $94,713 fair price, cheaper than 91% of 70 comparable listings.$29,936 under
2022Base48,294 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXNapleton's Volkswagen of SanfordSanford, FLCars.comView
2023 Base
$70,700
Great deal — $27,396 (28%) below the $98,096 fair price, cheaper than 90% of 70 comparable listings.$27,396 under
2023Base42,914 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXMaserati of MonmouthOcean, NJCars.comView
2019 Base
$70,975NEW
Great deal — $23,715 (25%) below the $94,690 fair price, cheaper than 89% of 70 comparable listings.$23,715 under
2019Base43,162 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXBMW of RidgefieldRidgefield, CTCars.comView
2021 Base
$72,677NEW
Great deal — $23,214 (24%) below the $95,891 fair price, cheaper than 87% of 70 comparable listings.$23,214 under
2021Base45,782 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXPower Motors EastMassapequa Park, NYCars.comView
2022 Base
$73,134
listed 48+ days
Great deal — $25,794 (26%) below the $98,928 fair price, cheaper than 86% of 70 comparable listings.$25,794 under
2022Base29,956 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXLynnes HyundaiBloomfield, NJCars.comView
2021 Base
$73,792
listed 48+ days
Great deal — $21,532 (23%) below the $95,324 fair price, cheaper than 84% of 70 comparable listings.$21,532 under
2021Base39,809 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXEast Hills Subaru of SayvilleSayville, NYCars.comView
2023 Base
$74,880
Great deal — $23,544 (24%) below the $98,424 fair price, cheaper than 83% of 70 comparable listings.$23,544 under
2023Base40,705 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXLorenzo Buick GMCMiami, FLCars.comView
2022 Base
$74,993NEW
Great deal — $23,600 (24%) below the $98,593 fair price, cheaper than 81% of 70 comparable listings.$23,600 under
2022Base27,327 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXThe Platinum Collection LLCDelray Beach, FLCars.comView
2021 Base
$74,999
Great deal — $23,952 (24%) below the $98,951 fair price, cheaper than 80% of 70 comparable listings.$23,952 under
2021Base31,148 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXLarin Automotive LLCNorwood, MACars.comView
2020 Competition
$75,373
Good deal — $7,207 (9%) below the $82,580 fair price, cheaper than 67% and lower mileage than 58% of 12 comparable listings.$7,207 under
2020Competition25,557 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXMotor Cars of ChicagoJoliet, ILCars.comView
2022 Base
$75,889NEW
Great deal — $19,482 (20%) below the $95,371 fair price, cheaper than 79% of 70 comparable listings.$19,482 under
2022Base40,779 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXMiracle AutosportHamilton Township, NJCars.comView
2023 Competition
$76,246
Good deal — $8,116 (10%) below the $84,362 fair price, cheaper than 58% of 12 comparable listings.$8,116 under
2023Competition41,911 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXSweis INFINITI MerrillvilleMerrillville, INCars.comView
2023 Base
$76,888
Great deal — $23,388 (23%) below the $100,276 fair price, cheaper than 77% of 70 comparable listings.$23,388 under
2023Base35,820 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXBMW of HonoluluHonolulu, HICars.comView
2021 Competition
$81,388NEW
Great deal — $5,173 (6%) below the $86,561 fair price, cheaper than 50% and lower mileage than 92% of 12 comparable listings.$5,173 under
2021Competition6,930 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXPerformance Luxury SportMarysville, OHCars.comView
2023 Base
$82,895
Great deal — $15,728 (16%) below the $98,623 fair price, cheaper than 76% of 70 comparable listings.$15,728 under
2023Base39,240 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXHigh Demand—Cars.comView
2022 Base
$82,950
Good deal — $15,423 (16%) below the $98,373 fair price, cheaper than 74% of 70 comparable listings.$15,423 under
2022Base23,728 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXAuto Collection of MurfreesboroMurfreesboro, TNCars.comView
2023 Base
$83,139
listed 48+ days
Great deal — $18,046 (18%) below the $101,185 fair price, cheaper than 73% of 70 comparable listings.$18,046 under
2023Base33,950 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXBommarito ToyotaHazelwood, MOCars.comView
2023 Base
$83,200
Great deal — $17,512 (17%) below the $100,712 fair price, cheaper than 71% of 70 comparable listings.$17,512 under
2023Base30,817 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXMountain View ChevroletChattanooga, TNCars.comView
2023 Base
$83,580
Great deal — $17,166 (17%) below the $100,746 fair price, cheaper than 70% of 70 comparable listings.$17,166 under
2023Base30,158 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXSterling BMWNewport Beach, CACars.comView
2022 Base
$83,890
Great deal — $15,085 (15%) below the $98,975 fair price, cheaper than 69% of 70 comparable listings.$15,085 under
2022Base26,410 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXRocky Mountain Eurosport ParkerParker, COCars.comView
2023 Base
$83,995NEW
Great deal — $16,802 (17%) below the $100,797 fair price, cheaper than 67% of 70 comparable listings.$16,802 under
2023Base25,183 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXHigh Demand—Cars.comView
2023 Base
$84,280
Good deal — $16,612 (16%) below the $100,892 fair price, cheaper than 66% of 70 comparable listings.$16,612 under
2023Base26,554 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXCoast to Coast ImportsFort Lauderdale, FLCars.comView
2022 Base
$84,495
Good deal — $13,876 (14%) below the $98,371 fair price, cheaper than 64% of 70 comparable listings.$13,876 under
2022Base24,656 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXAutobahn USA WestboroughWestboro, MACars.comView
2023 Base
$84,777NEW
Great deal — $15,605 (16%) below the $100,382 fair price, cheaper than 63% of 70 comparable listings.$15,605 under
2023Base32,486 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXFDS Luxury AutoSan Antonio, TXCars.comView
2023 Base
$84,845
Great deal — $15,629 (16%) below the $100,474 fair price, cheaper than 61% of 70 comparable listings.$15,629 under
2023Base31,751 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXPrime Motor CoPortland, ORCars.comView

Highlighted rows = accident history not shown by the listing; confirm via CARFAX before purchase. CarGurus prices may include dealer fees, so a duplicate car is priced from Cars.com / Autotrader where available.

Market price trend

as of 2026-08-04
$96K▲ 3.6% over 4 wks
Median asking price of listed BMW M5 inventory over time — reflects what's for sale, not a single car's value.

How the BMW M5 market moves

modeled from 85 live listings
−5.5%/yrlost to age, miles held equal
−$7K/10k mivalue cost of every 10,000 miles
$98Ktypical asking today
Estimated value vs. mileage · higher-mileage cars sit lower on the curve

Trend forecast: ≈ −$12K over the next 12 months · at ~10k mi/yr, depreciation only — excludes market swings

Market: German asking prices are down 1.5% over the last 10 weeks, holding model, mileage and age constant. · a separate signal from depreciation, not added to it

What each trim is worth · vs. Base, same age & miles
  • Base72baseline
  • Competition12+$4K

More German cars

Browse all →
BMW M8148 listings · 35 greatAudi S395 listings · 25 greatMercedes-AMG CLA3574 listings · 25 greatMercedes-AMG E 53100 listings · 24 greatBMW M2102 listings · 21 greatAudi RS 591 listings · 21 great