All models

BMW Z4 M40i

GermanNationwide US · 45 listings · 9 great deals · updated 2026-11-11
All listings
45 cars
Cheapest
$35,741
Average
$45,425
Great deals
9
Verify CARFAX
40 flagged

Deal breakdown

37 priced vs. fair value · click to filter · how?
Great Deal 9Good Deal 5Fair Price 10High 3Overpriced 10
Median price $42,169Median miles 30,000
★ Best deal right now
$44,973
2020 M40i · 13,636 mi
$9,348 under fair value (fair $54,321)
Fair range $27,750–$55,136 · vs 40 comparable listings

Price vs. mileage

each dot is a listing · line = market trend · dots below the line are better value
$33K$44K$54K$65K$75K025k50k75k100kMileage2020 M40i — $35,741 · 57,751 mi · Great Deal2020 M40i — $36,000 · 52,000 mi · Great Deal2020 M40i — $36,988 · 46,000 mi · Fair Price2020 M40i — $38,225 · 49,025 mi · Great Deal2020 M40i — $38,249 · 34,497 mi · Great Deal2020 M40i — $38,295 · 37,822 mi · Great Deal2020 M40i — $38,387 · 28,000 mi · Great Deal2020 M40i — $38,650 · 50,000 mi · Great Deal2020 M40i — $38,977 · 39,000 mi · Great Deal2020 M40i — $39,092 · 57,000 mi · Great Deal2020 M40i — $39,158 · 37,000 mi · Good Deal2020 sDrive M40i — $39,416 · 39,517 mi2021 M40i — $39,799 · 51,000 mi · Fair Price2020 M40i — $39,889 · 44,406 mi · Fair Price2020 M40i — $40,040 · 41,000 mi · Good Deal2020 M40i — $40,389 · 44,000 mi · Fair Price2020 M40i — $40,590 · 30,924 mi · Fair Price2020 M40i — $40,790 · 30,000 mi · Fair Price2020 M40i — $40,995 · 26,947 mi · Fair Price2020 M40i — $41,000 · 34,905 mi · Fair Price2020 M40i — $41,395 · 26,000 mi · High2020 M40i — $42,080 · 38,081 mi · Fair Price2020 M40i — $42,169 · 24,205 mi · Good Deal2020 M40i — $42,967 · 21,584 mi · Good Deal2020 sDrive M40i — $42,990 · 44,599 mi2020 M40i — $44,973 · 13,636 mi · Good Deal2022 M40i — $47,500 · 14,500 mi · Fair Price2022 M40i — $47,705 · 29,276 mi · High2023 M40i — $47,956 · 22,826 mi · High2020 M40I — $48,998 · 27,752 mi2022 M40i — $49,584 · 31,789 mi · Overpriced2022 sDrive M40i — $49,750 · 24,106 mi2024 M40i — $49,900 · 30,616 mi · Overpriced2024 sDrive M40i — $50,680 · 47,276 mi2022 sDrive M40i — $51,489 · 16,670 mi2022 M40i — $51,990 · 17,139 mi · Overpriced2022 M40I — $51,998 · 15,007 mi2022 M40i — $52,485 · 17,866 mi · Overpriced2023 M40i — $52,730 · 20,370 mi · Overpriced2022 M40i — $52,997 · 12,351 mi · Overpriced2023 M40i — $53,998 · 17,890 mi · Overpriced2022 M40i — $54,103 · 14,000 mi · Overpriced2024 M40i Roadster — $58,900 · 10,905 mi2025 M40i — $60,985 · 15,000 mi · Overpriced2025 M40i — $73,117 · 943 mi · Overpriced
CompareExport Excel45 cars
–
–
Trim
Transmission24% have this
Source
Deal
Price▲YearTrimBodyMileageAccident / Title HistoryDealerLocationSource
2020 M40i
$35,741
Great deal — $3,894 (10%) below the $39,635 fair price, cheaper than 98% of 40 comparable listings.$3,894 under
2020M40i57,751 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXFoley INFINITI of ShrewsburyShrewsbury, MACars.comView
2020 M40i
$36,000
Great deal — $3,666 (9%) below the $39,666 fair price, cheaper than 95% of 40 comparable listings.$3,666 under
2020M40i52,000 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXPrivate seller: DimitriosFarmington, NYCars.comView
$36,988
Fair price — $680 (2%) above the $36,308 fair price, cheaper than 92% of 40 comparable listings.
2020M40i46,000 miACCIDENT/damage REPORTEDLovering Auto SalesLakeland, FLAutotraderView
2020 M40i
$38,225NEW
Great deal — $1,350 (3%) below the $39,575 fair price, cheaper than 90% of 40 comparable listings.$1,350 under
2020M40i49,025 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXGood Deal High Demand—Cars.comView
2020 M40i
$38,249
↓ $25 this weeklisted 72+ days
Great deal — $3,795 (9%) below the $42,044 fair price, cheaper than 88% of 40 comparable listings.$3,795 under
2020M40i34,497 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXBMW of Columbia - MOColumbia, MOCars.comView
2020 M40i
$38,295
Great deal — $2,497 (6%) below the $40,792 fair price, cheaper than 85% of 40 comparable listings.$2,497 under
2020M40i37,822 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXGreat Deal High Demand—Cars.comView
$38,387
Great deal — $3,934 (9%) below the $42,321 fair price, cheaper than 82% and lower mileage than 52% of 40 comparable listings.$3,934 under
2020M40i28,000 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXGreat PricePalm Harbor, FLAutotraderView
$38,650
Great deal — $1,194 (3%) below the $39,844 fair price, cheaper than 80% of 40 comparable listings.$1,194 under
2020M40i50,000 miNo accidents (Autotrader report)Specialties Auto Group, LLCBountiful, UTAutotraderView
$38,977
Great deal — $2,335 (6%) below the $41,312 fair price, cheaper than 78% of 40 comparable listings.$2,335 under
2020M40i39,000 miNo accidents (Autotrader report)Motion AutosportNorth Canton, OHAutotraderView
$39,092
Great deal — $678 (2%) below the $39,770 fair price, cheaper than 75% of 40 comparable listings.
2020M40i57,000 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXGood PriceCumming, GAAutotraderView
$39,158
Good deal — $2,742 (7%) below the $41,900 fair price, cheaper than 72% of 40 comparable listings.$2,742 under
2020M40i37,000 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXGreat PriceAustin, TXAutotraderView
2020 sDrive M40i
$39,416
2020sDrive M40i39,517 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXMotion AutosportNorth Canton, OHCars.comView
$39,799
Fair price — $426 (1%) above the $39,373 fair price, cheaper than 70% of 40 comparable listings.
2021M40i51,000 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXGreat Price—AutotraderView
2020 M40i
$39,889NEW
Fair price — $277 (1%) above the $39,612 fair price, cheaper than 68% of 40 comparable listings.
2020M40i44,406 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXGood Deal High Demand—Cars.comView
$40,040
Good deal — $1,583 (4%) below the $41,623 fair price, cheaper than 65% of 40 comparable listings.$1,583 under
2020M40i41,000 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXGreat Price—AutotraderView
$40,389
Fair price — $556 (1%) above the $39,833 fair price, cheaper than 62% of 40 comparable listings.
2020M40i44,000 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXGood Price—AutotraderView
2020 M40i
$40,590
Fair price — $989 (2%) below the $41,579 fair price, cheaper than 60% of 40 comparable listings.$989 under
2020M40i30,924 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXJ&S Autohaus SixMount Holly, NJCars.comView
$40,790
Fair price — $640 (2%) below the $41,430 fair price, cheaper than 57% of 40 comparable listings.
2020M40i30,000 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXGreat Price—AutotraderView
2020 M40i
$40,995
↓ $135 this week
Fair price — $294 (1%) below the $41,289 fair price, cheaper than 55% and lower mileage than 57% of 40 comparable listings.
2020M40i26,947 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXHigh Demand—Cars.comView
2020 M40i
$41,000
listed 72+ days
Fair price — $908 (2%) below the $41,908 fair price, cheaper than 52% of 40 comparable listings.$908 under
2020M40i34,905 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXSR AUTO GROUPQuincy, MACars.comView
$41,395
Priced high — $2,169 (6%) above the $39,226 fair price, cheaper than 50% and lower mileage than 60% of 40 comparable listings.$2,169 over
2020M40i26,000 miACCIDENT/damage REPORTEDSponsored by Aloha Auto DepotHonolulu, HIAutotraderView
2020 M40i
$42,080
Fair price — $840 (2%) above the $41,240 fair price for 40 comparable listings.$840 over
2020M40i38,081 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXUnique Motors Seattle LLCKent, WACars.comView
2020 M40i
$42,169
Good deal — $1,612 (4%) below the $43,781 fair price, lower mileage than 62% of 40 comparable listings.$1,612 under
2020M40i24,205 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXBeverly Hills BMWLA, CACars.comView
2020 M40i
$42,967
Good deal — $1,663 (4%) below the $44,630 fair price, lower mileage than 68% of 40 comparable listings.$1,663 under
2020M40i21,584 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXGood Deal High Demand—Cars.comView
2020 sDrive M40i
$42,990
2020sDrive M40i44,599 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXAutomotive ImportsDenver, COCars.comView
2020 M40i
$44,973
Good deal — $9,348 (17%) below the $54,321 fair price, lower mileage than 90% of 40 comparable listings.$9,348 under
2020M40i13,636 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXGood Deal High Demand—Cars.comView
2022 M40i
$47,500
Fair price — $1,412 (3%) above the $46,088 fair price, lower mileage than 85% of 40 comparable listings.$1,412 over
2022M40i14,500 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXPrivate seller: SinanCampbell, CACars.comView
2022 M40i
$47,705
Priced high — $5,570 (13%) above the $42,135 fair price, lower mileage than 50% of 40 comparable listings.$5,570 over
2022M40i29,276 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXPat Milliken FordRedford, MICars.comView
2023 M40i
$47,956
Priced high — $5,272 (12%) above the $42,684 fair price, lower mileage than 65% of 40 comparable listings.$5,272 over
2023M40i22,826 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXBMW of SalemSalem, ORCars.comView
2020 M40I
$48,998
2020M40I27,752 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXCarMax North AttleboroNorth Attleborough, MACars.comView
2022 M40i
$49,584
Overpriced — $7,886 (19%) above the $41,698 fair price for 40 comparable listings.$7,886 over
2022M40i31,789 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXMercedes-Benz of Hilton HeadBluffton, SCCars.comView
2022 sDrive M40i
$49,750
↓ $800 this weeklisted 72+ days
2022sDrive M40i24,106 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXAutoBayBurlington, NJCars.comView
2024 M40i
$49,900
Overpriced — $7,249 (17%) above the $42,651 fair price for 40 comparable listings.$7,249 over
2024M40i30,616 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXUnlimited MotorsWestfield, INCars.comView
2024 sDrive M40i
$50,680
2024sDrive M40i47,276 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXEuro Motorcars BethesdaBethesda, MDCars.comView
2022 sDrive M40i
$51,489
2022sDrive M40i16,670 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXNew Motors AutoMall - BMW Subaru VolkswagenErie, PACars.comView
2022 M40i
$51,990
Overpriced — $6,833 (15%) above the $45,157 fair price, lower mileage than 78% of 40 comparable listings.$6,833 over
2022M40i17,139 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXD & C Motor CompanyPortland, ORCars.comView
2022 M40I
$51,998
2022M40I15,007 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXCarMax JacksonvilleJacksonville, FLCars.comView
2022 M40i
$52,485
Overpriced — $7,702 (17%) above the $44,783 fair price, lower mileage than 75% of 40 comparable listings.$7,702 over
2022M40i17,866 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXAutoLenders ExtonExton, PACars.comView
2023 M40i
$52,730
Overpriced — $10,111 (24%) above the $42,619 fair price, lower mileage than 70% of 40 comparable listings.$10,111 over
2023M40i20,370 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXApple Lease ReturnsAustin, TXCars.comView
2022 M40i
$52,997
↓ $400 this week
Overpriced — $1,285 (2%) above the $51,712 fair price, lower mileage than 92% of 40 comparable listings.$1,285 over
2022M40i12,351 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXHusker High LineLincoln, NECars.comView
2023 M40i
$53,998
Overpriced — $9,256 (21%) above the $44,742 fair price, lower mileage than 72% of 40 comparable listings.$9,256 over
2023M40i17,890 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXCarMax AthensAthens, GACars.comView
$54,103
Overpriced — $4,056 (8%) above the $50,047 fair price, lower mileage than 88% of 40 comparable listings.$4,056 over
2022M40i14,000 miNo accidents (Autotrader report)Good PriceJupiter, FLAutotraderView
2024 M40i Roadster
$58,900
2024M40i RoadsterConvertible10,905 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAX—eBayView
$60,985
Overpriced — $14,251 (30%) above the $46,734 fair price, lower mileage than 82% of 40 comparable listings.$14,251 over
2025M40i15,000 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXGreat PriceLake Bluff, ILAutotraderView
$73,117
Overpriced — $11,823 (19%) above the $61,294 fair price, lower mileage than 98% of 40 comparable listings.$11,823 over
2025M40i943 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXDealer Fees IncludedCarlsbad, CAAutotraderView

Highlighted rows = accident history not shown by the listing; confirm via CARFAX before purchase. CarGurus prices may include dealer fees, so a duplicate car is priced from Cars.com / Autotrader where available.

Market price trend

as of 2026-11-11
$42K▼ 6.3% over 17 wks
Median asking price of listed BMW Z4 M40i inventory over time — reflects what's for sale, not a single car's value.

How the BMW Z4 M40i market moves

modeled from 43 live listings
−6.6%/yrlost to age, miles held equal
−$2K/10k mivalue cost of every 10,000 miles
$43Ktypical asking today
Estimated value vs. mileage · higher-mileage cars sit lower on the curve

Trend forecast: ≈ −$5K over the next 12 months · at ~10k mi/yr, depreciation only — excludes market swings

Market: German asking prices are down 1.4% over the last 20 weeks, holding model, mileage and age constant. · a separate signal from depreciation, not added to it

More German cars

Browse all →
Audi S3169 listings · 49 greatBMW M8176 listings · 45 greatMercedes-AMG C43171 listings · 42 greatMercedes-AMG E 53146 listings · 41 greatAudi S4179 listings · 40 greatBMW M5173 listings · 38 great