Ferrari 458 Italia

SupercarNationwide US · 92 listings · updated 2026-11-11

All listings

92 cars

Cheapest

$189,900

Average

$358,239

Great deals

Verify CARFAX

78 flagged

Deal breakdown

3 priced vs. fair value · click to filter · how?

Fair Price 1High 2

Median price $350,035Median miles 18,222

★ Best deal right now

$399,935

2013 Base · 5,450 mi

$2,110 under fair value (fair $402,045)

Fair range $201,023–$525,370 · vs 83 comparable listings

Price vs. mileage

each dot is a listing · line = market trend · dots below the line are better value

Compare Export Excel92 cars

Sort

Price ($)

–

Year

–

Max miles

History

State

Near ZIP

Trim

Transmission8% have this

Source

Deal

Price▲	Year	Trim	Body	Mileage	Accident / Title History	Dealer	Location	Source
$189,900	2012	Base		35,502 mi	Rebuilt title	Gallery Junction Inc	Orange, CA	Cars.com	View
$239,995 listed 61+ days	2013	Base		19,827 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Houston Auto World	Houston, TX	Cars.com	View
$256,581	2010	Base		13,821 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Tampa Auto Gallery Sales & Leasing	Tampa, FL	Cars.com	View
$264,698	2012	Base		37,501 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Reed Nissan Clermont	Clermont, FL	Cars.com	View
$264,990	2011	Base		38,172 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Elite Motor Cars	Concord, CA	Cars.com	View
$276,389	2010	Base		35,709 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Exotic Knights	Orlando, FL	Cars.com	View
$277,899	2010	Base		29,463 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Luxury Auto Collection	Scottsdale, AZ	Cars.com	View
$279,900	2011	Base		39,693 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Tactical Fleet Dallas	Dallas, TX	Cars.com	View
$279,942 listed 61+ days	2010	Base		37,761 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Ferrari Silicon Valley	Redwood City, CA	Cars.com	View
$290,379	2014	Base		7,205 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	The Collezione By THECARWIZ	Las Vegas, NV	Cars.com	View
$291,389	2014	Base		35,543 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Exotic Knights	Orlando, FL	Cars.com	View
$295,599	2014	Base		24,607 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	RP Exotics	Saint Louis, MO	Cars.com	View
$298,081 listed 61+ days	2011	Base		23,403 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Tampa Auto Gallery Sales & Leasing	Tampa, FL	Cars.com	View
$298,082 listed 61+ days	2010	Base		21,290 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Tampa Auto Gallery Sales & Leasing	Tampa, FL	Cars.com	View
$299,900 listed 129+ days	2011	Base		25,845 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Tactical Fleet Charlotte	Charlotte, NC	Cars.com	View
$299,995 ↓ $20,000 this weeklisted 61+ days	2013	Base		15,978 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Haus of Lux	Wayne, NJ	Cars.com	View
$300,062	2014	Base		35,440 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Ferrari Silicon Valley	Redwood City, CA	Cars.com	View
$300,373	2013	Base		28,176 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Motor Cars of Chicago	Joliet, IL	Cars.com	View
$319,900 listed 76+ days	2011	Coupe		25,000 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Dealer Fees Included	Charlotte, NC	Autotrader	View
$320,163	2011	Base		24,072 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Ron Tonkin Gran Turismo	Wilsonville, OR	Cars.com	View
$326,581 listed 61+ days	2014	Base		19,703 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Tampa Auto Gallery Sales & Leasing	Tampa, FL	Cars.com	View
$326,598	2014	Base		5,605 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Scottsdale Maserati	Phoenix, AZ	Cars.com	View
$327,248 ↓ $2,998 this week	2011	Base		16,155 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Penske Honda	Indianapolis, IN	Cars.com	View
$328,880 listed 76+ days	2010	Coupe		37,000 mi	No accidents (Autotrader badge)	Ferrari Silicon Valley	Redwood City, CA	Autotrader	View
$329,000	2013	Base		19,283 mi	No accidents/damage reported Clean title	Ilusso Houston	Houston, TX	Cars.com	View
$329,730	2012	Base		24,172 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Automotive Addiction	Murray, UT	Cars.com	View
$329,990 listed 61+ days	2010	Base		25,385 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Foreign Cars Italia (Now Hendrick)	Greensboro, NC	Cars.com	View
$330,000 listed 61+ days	2010	Coupe		28,000 mi	No accidents (Autotrader badge)	Private Seller Exchange	El Dorado Hills, CA	Autotrader	View
$331,190	2011	Base		35,439 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Exclusive Automotive Group	Ashburn, VA	Cars.com	View
$332,825	2012	458 Italia		25,198 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Wide World Ferrari	Spring Valley, NY	Cars.com	View
$338,376 ↓ $5,161 this weeklisted 61+ days	2012	Base		31,181 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Porsche Norwell	Norwell, MA	Cars.com	View
$338,581 listed 76+ days	2011	Coupe		23,000 mi	No accidents (Autotrader badge)	Tampa Auto Gallery Sales & Leasing	Tampa, FL	Autotrader	View
$339,063 listed 61+ days	2014	458 Italia		21,239 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Wide World Ferrari	Spring Valley, NY	Cars.com	View
$339,085	2013	Base		20,046 mi	No accidents/damage reported Clean title	Ilusso	Costa Mesa, CA	Cars.com	View
$339,888	2011	Base		18,167 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Mark Motors	Boerne, TX	Cars.com	View
$340,400	2011	Base		12,134 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Purmotive	—	Cars.com	View
$341,389 listed 61+ days	2014	Coupe		35,000 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Dealer Fees Included	—	Autotrader	View
$341,393 ↓ $10,000 this week	2015	Base		16,922 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Atlanta Autos	Marietta, GA	Cars.com	View
$341,696	2012	Base		19,725 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Prestige Imports	Miami, FL	Cars.com	View
$344,675 listed 61+ days	2013	Base		17,772 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Ferrari Dallas	Plano, TX	Cars.com	View
$344,888 listed 61+ days	2010	Base		20,822 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Mark Motors	Boerne, TX	Cars.com	View
$346,697 listed 76+ days	2012	Coupe		19,000 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Dealer Fees Included	—	Autotrader	View
$347,990	2012	Base		16,229 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	D & C Motor Company	Portland, OR	Cars.com	View
$348,282 ↓ $11,773 this week	2011	Base		23,119 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Ferrari of San Francisco	Mill Valley, CA	Cars.com	View
$348,995 listed 76+ days High$71,124 over	2014	Coupe		30,000 mi	No accidents (Autotrader badge)	European Exotic Center	—	Autotrader	View
$349,995 listed 61+ days	2011	Coupe		25,000 mi	No accidents (Autotrader badge)	European Exotic Center	—	Autotrader	View
$350,075	2012	458 Italia		23,080 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Ferrari of Long Island	Plainview, NY	Cars.com	View
$350,411	2012	Base		25,552 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Continental Ferrari	Hinsdale, IL	Cars.com	View
$352,590 ↓ $17,431 this weeklisted 61+ days	2013	Base		23,639 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Ferrari of San Francisco	Mill Valley, CA	Cars.com	View
$361,189 listed 61+ days	2011	Base		17,698 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Maserati of Central Florida	Orlando, FL	Cars.com	View
$362,675	2014	Base		11,427 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Ferrari Dallas	Plano, TX	Cars.com	View
$365,995 listed 76+ days	2013	Coupe		15,000 mi	No accidents (Autotrader badge)	The Car House Of Wayne LLC	—	Autotrader	View
$366,081 listed 76+ days	2014	Coupe		19,000 mi	No accidents (Autotrader badge)	Tampa Auto Gallery Sales & Leasing	—	Autotrader	View
$369,888	2012	Base		22,031 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Mark Motors	Boerne, TX	Cars.com	View
$369,995 listed 61+ days	2010	Base		16,976 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	TBTFW	Beverly Hills, CA	Cars.com	View
$375,560 listed 101+ days	2012	Base		12,667 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Maserati of Cleveland	Cleveland, OH	Cars.com	View
$377,244 listed 76+ days	2013	Coupe		17,000 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Dealer Fees Included	—	Autotrader	View
$377,675 listed 61+ days	2015	Base		22,127 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Ferrari Dallas	Plano, TX	Cars.com	View
$378,000 listed 61+ days	2010	Base		16,300 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	ZTR Autohaus	Phoenix, AZ	Cars.com	View
$379,708 listed 61+ days	2010	Coupe		20,000 mi	No accidents (Autotrader badge)	Mark Motors	—	Autotrader	View
$379,950 listed 76+ days	2012	Coupe		18,000 mi	No accidents (Autotrader badge)	Land Rover Van Nuys	—	Autotrader	View
$379,995	2015	Base		13,317 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	TBTFW	Beverly Hills, CA	Cars.com	View
$380,170	2014	458 Italia		16,678 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Wide World Ferrari	Spring Valley, NY	Cars.com	View
$380,412 listed 76+ days	2012	Coupe		24,000 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Dealer Fees Included	—	Autotrader	View
$382,533	2011	Base		13,386 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Ron Tonkin Gran Turismo	Wilsonville, OR	Cars.com	View
$382,696	2012	458 Italia		11,144 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Wide World Ferrari	Spring Valley, NY	Cars.com	View
$389,000 listed 61+ days	2010	Base		8,313 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Ferrari Lake Forest	Lake Bluff, IL	Cars.com	View
$389,798 listed 61+ days	2014	Base		8,842 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Earth MotorCars / Lotus of Dallas	Carrollton, TX	Cars.com	View
$389,888 listed 61+ days	2012	Coupe		21,000 mi	No accidents (Autotrader badge)	Sponsored by Mark Motors Austin	Round Rock, TX	Autotrader	View
$389,995 listed 61+ days	2011	Base		11,270 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Ryan Friedman Motor Cars	Glen Cove, NY	Cars.com	View
$389,999	2013	2dr Convertible	Convertible	13,236 mi	No accidents/damage reported Clean title		—	eBay	View
$390,411 listed 101+ days	2011	Base		7,875 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Continental Ferrari	Hinsdale, IL	Cars.com	View
$390,582	2011	458 Italia		7,146 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Ferrari of Naples	Naples, FL	Cars.com	View
$398,798 listed 61+ days	2012	Base		16,601 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Foreign Cars Italia Charlotte (Now Hendrick)	Charlotte, NC	Cars.com	View
$399,589	2012	458 Italia		14,849 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Ferrari of Palm Beach	West Palm Beach, FL	Cars.com	View
$399,900	2010	Base		12,985 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Black Horse Motors	Naples, FL	Cars.com	View
$399,935 Fair Price$2,110 under	2013	Base		5,450 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Ferrari South Bay	Torrance, CA	Cars.com	View
$400,345 listed 76+ days	2015	Base		18,276 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	SR Auto Group	Bayside, NY	Cars.com	View
$409,995 High$18,606 over	2014	Base		8,335 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Ryan Friedman Motor Cars	Glen Cove, NY	Cars.com	View
$419,990	2012	Base		12,275 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Foreign Cars Italia (Now Hendrick)	Greensboro, NC	Cars.com	View
$419,995	2010	Base		9,825 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Skyway Motors Cars	Palmetto, FL	Cars.com	View
$429,995	2015	Base		4,383 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Ryan Friedman Motor Cars	Glen Cove, NY	Cars.com	View
$439,989	2010	Base		3,393 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Cavallino Rosso St Louis	Maplewood, MO	Cars.com	View
$439,995 listed 61+ days	2012	Base		2,410 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Gulf Coast Motorworks	Bonita Springs, FL	Cars.com	View
$450,694	2013	458 Italia		10,542 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Ferrari of Naples	Naples, FL	Cars.com	View
$451,584	2012	Base		8,161 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Ferrari Maserati Alfa Romeo of Fort Lauderdale	Fort Lauderdale, FL	Cars.com	View
$460,412 listed 76+ days	2011	Coupe		7,000 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Dealer Fees Included	Hinsdale, IL	Autotrader	View
$460,694	2014	Base		4,687 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Exotic Motorsports of Oklahoma	Edmond, OK	Cars.com	View
$469,990	2014	Base		7,898 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Ferrari of Newport Beach	Newport Beach, CA	Cars.com	View
$476,062	2013	Base		18,057 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Ferrari Westlake	Thousand Oaks, CA	Cars.com	View
$489,914	2015	Base		4,628 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Eurocar	Costa Mesa, CA	Cars.com	View
$559,914	2015	Base		1,818 mi	History not shown - CHECK CARFAX	Eurocar	Costa Mesa, CA	Cars.com	View

Highlighted rows = accident history not shown by the listing; confirm via CARFAX before purchase. CarGurus prices may include dealer fees, so a duplicate car is priced from Cars.com / Autotrader where available.

Market price trend

as of 2026-11-11

$350K▲ 6.1% over 18 wks

Median asking price of listed Ferrari 458 Italia inventory over time — reflects what's for sale, not a single car's value.

How the Ferrari 458 Italia market moves

modeled from 91 live listings

−0.8%/yrlost to age, miles held equal

−$40K/10k mivalue cost of every 10,000 miles

$350Ktypical asking today

Estimated value vs. mileage · higher-mileage cars sit lower on the curve

Trend forecast: ≈ −$43K over the next 12 months · at ~10k mi/yr, depreciation only — excludes market swings

Market: Supercar asking prices are up 3.4% over the last 19 weeks, holding model, mileage and age constant. · a separate signal from depreciation, not added to it

Ferrari 458 Italia

Deal breakdown

Price vs. mileage

Market price trend

How the Ferrari 458 Italia market moves

More Supercar cars