All listings
50 cars
Cheapest
$160,000
Average
$371,083
Great deals
0
Verify CARFAX
35 flagged
Deal breakdown
45 priced vs. fair value · click to filter · how?Good Deal 20Fair Price 11High 5Overpriced 9
Median price $366,033Median miles 19,000
★ Best deal right now
$299,900
2012 Base · 19,477 mi
$69,491 under fair value (fair $369,391)
Fair range $185,329–$383,591 · vs 46 comparable listings
Cheaper than 91% of comparable listings
Price vs. mileage
each dot is a listing · line = market trend · dots below the line are better value–
–
Trim
Source
Deal
| Price▲ | Year | Trim | Body | Mileage | Accident / Title History | Dealer | Location | Source | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
 | listed 56+ days | 2014 | 458 Italia | 17,256 mi | History not shown - CHECK CARFAX | Ferrari of San Diego | San Diego, CA | Cars.com | View | ||
$200,889NEW | 2011 | Coupe | 36,000 mi | History not shown - CHECK CARFAX | Miracle Autosport | Mercerville, NJ | Autotrader | View | |||
$269,000NEW | 2014 | Coupe 2D | 3,000 mi | No accidents (Autotrader badge) | Private Seller Exchange | Sudbury, MA | Autotrader | View | |||
$299,000NEW Good DealGood deal — $64,401 (18%) below the $363,401 fair price, cheaper than 96% of 46 comparable listings.$64,401 under | 2010 | Coupe | 29,000 mi | No accidents (Autotrader badge) | ILUSSO LLC | Boynton Beach, FL | Autotrader | View | |||
$299,683NEW Good DealGood deal — $54,855 (15%) below the $354,538 fair price, cheaper than 93% of 46 comparable listings.$54,855 under | 2012 | Coupe | 37,000 mi | History not shown - CHECK CARFAX | Dealer Fees Included | Carrollton, TX | Autotrader | View | |||
 | listed 56+ days Good DealGood deal — $69,491 (19%) below the $369,391 fair price, cheaper than 91% of 46 comparable listings.$69,491 under | 2012 | Base | 19,477 mi | History not shown - CHECK CARFAX | Exotic Knights | Orlando, FL | Cars.com | View | ||
 | listed 56+ days Good DealGood deal — $51,983 (15%) below the $351,908 fair price, cheaper than 89% of 46 comparable listings.$51,983 under | 2012 | Base | 37,029 mi | History not shown - CHECK CARFAX | Earth MotorCars / Lotus of Dallas | Carrollton, TX | Cars.com | View | ||
 | Good DealGood deal — $59,988 (16%) below the $365,787 fair price, cheaper than 87% of 46 comparable listings.$59,988 under | 2012 | Base | 22,031 mi | History not shown - CHECK CARFAX | Stevenson Hendrick Mazda Wilmington | Wilmington, NC | Cars.com | View | ||
 | listed 56+ days Good DealGood deal — $43,528 (12%) below the $353,428 fair price, cheaper than 85% of 46 comparable listings.$43,528 under | 2012 | Base | 36,636 mi | History not shown - CHECK CARFAX | Tactical Fleet Dallas | Dallas, TX | Cars.com | View | ||
$329,389NEW Good DealGood deal — $18,718 (5%) below the $348,107 fair price, cheaper than 83% of 46 comparable listings.$18,718 under | 2010 | Coupe | 35,000 mi | History not shown - CHECK CARFAX | Dealer Fees Included | Orlando, FL | Autotrader | View | |||
$329,990NEW Good DealGood deal — $23,439 (7%) below the $353,429 fair price, cheaper than 80% of 46 comparable listings.$23,439 under | 2010 | Coupe | 37,000 mi | No accidents (Autotrader badge) | Ferrari Silicon Valley | Redwood City, CA | Autotrader | View | |||
$331,190NEW Good DealGood deal — $22,420 (6%) below the $353,610 fair price, cheaper than 77% of 46 comparable listings.$22,420 under | 2011 | Coupe | 35,000 mi | History not shown - CHECK CARFAX | Dealer Fees Included | Ashburn, VA | Autotrader | View | |||
 | Good DealGood deal — $22,944 (6%) below the $354,134 fair price, cheaper than 77% of 46 comparable listings.$22,944 under | 2011 | Base | 35,439 mi | History not shown - CHECK CARFAX | Exclusive Automotive Group | Ashburn, VA | Cars.com | View | ||
$334,900NEW Good DealGood deal — $25,362 (7%) below the $360,262 fair price, cheaper than 73% of 46 comparable listings.$25,362 under | 2011 | Coupe | 25,000 mi | History not shown - CHECK CARFAX | Dealer Fees Included | Charlotte, NC | Autotrader | View | |||
 | listed 56+ days Good DealGood deal — $27,502 (8%) below the $362,402 fair price, cheaper than 73% of 46 comparable listings.$27,502 under | 2011 | Base | 25,838 mi | History not shown - CHECK CARFAX | Tactical Fleet Charlotte | Charlotte, NC | Cars.com | View | ||
 | listed 56+ days Good DealGood deal — $30,914 (8%) below the $366,713 fair price, cheaper than 70% of 46 comparable listings.$30,914 under | 2014 | Base | 21,969 mi | History not shown - CHECK CARFAX | Stevenson Hendrick Mazda Wilmington | Wilmington, NC | Cars.com | View | ||
 | listed 56+ days Good DealGood deal — $15,511 (4%) below the $353,196 fair price for 3 comparable listings. (Few comparables — lower confidence.)$15,511 under | 2011 | 458 Italia | 21,175 mi | History not shown - CHECK CARFAX | Ferrari of Naples | Naples, FL | Cars.com | View | ||
$339,581NEW Good DealGood deal — $20,302 (6%) below the $359,883 fair price, cheaper than 67% of 46 comparable listings.$20,302 under | 2011 | Coupe | 23,000 mi | No accidents (Autotrader badge) | Tampa Auto Gallery Sales & Leasing | Tampa, FL | Autotrader | View | |||
↓ $1,022 this week Good DealGood deal — $21,130 (6%) below the $370,130 fair price, cheaper than 64% of 46 comparable listings.$21,130 under | 2013 | Coupe | 20,000 mi | No accidents (Autotrader badge) | Ferrari Los Angeles | — | Autotrader | View | |||
$349,000NEW Fair PriceFair price — $345 (0%) below the $349,345 fair price, cheaper than 64% of 46 comparable listings. | 2011 | Coupe | 39,000 mi | No accidents (Autotrader badge) | ILUSSO LLC | — | Autotrader | View | |||
 | Good DealGood deal — $25,632 (7%) below the $375,617 fair price, cheaper than 61% of 46 comparable listings.$25,632 under | 2014 | Base | 19,702 mi | History not shown - CHECK CARFAX | Ilusso | Costa Mesa, CA | Cars.com | View | ||
$349,995NEW Fair PriceFair price — $10,505 (3%) below the $360,500 fair price, cheaper than 59% of 46 comparable listings.$10,505 under | 2014 | Coupe | 30,000 mi | No accidents (Autotrader badge) | European Exotic Center | — | Autotrader | View | |||
 | Good DealGood deal — $25,595 (7%) below the $375,617 fair price, cheaper than 57% of 46 comparable listings.$25,595 under | 2013 | Base | 20,005 mi | History not shown - CHECK CARFAX | Ferrari Los Angeles | Van Nuys, CA | Cars.com | View | ||
$351,697NEW Good DealGood deal — $21,350 (6%) below the $373,047 fair price, cheaper than 54% and lower mileage than 52% of 46 comparable listings.$21,350 under | 2012 | Coupe | 19,000 mi | History not shown - CHECK CARFAX | Dealer Fees Included | — | Autotrader | View | |||
$365,990NEW Fair PriceFair price — $5,094 (1%) below the $371,084 fair price, cheaper than 52% of 46 comparable listings.$5,094 under | 2011 | Coupe | 22,000 mi | No accidents (Autotrader badge) | Ferrari Silicon Valley | — | Autotrader | View | |||
 | Fair PriceFair price — $4,500 (1%) above the $361,575 fair price, cheaper than 50% of 46 comparable listings.$4,500 over | 2011 | Base | 22,954 mi | History not shown - CHECK CARFAX | Ferrari Silicon Valley | Redwood City, CA | Cars.com | View | ||
$369,000NEW Good DealGood deal — $16,004 (4%) below the $385,004 fair price, lower mileage than 87% of 46 comparable listings.$16,004 under | 2015 | Coupe | 7,000 mi | No accidents (Autotrader badge) | Henry Motors | — | Autotrader | View | |||
$374,581NEW Fair PriceFair price — $4,787 (1%) above the $369,794 fair price, lower mileage than 52% of 46 comparable listings.$4,787 over | 2014 | Coupe | 19,000 mi | No accidents (Autotrader badge) | Tampa Auto Gallery Sales & Leasing | — | Autotrader | View | |||
$375,000NEW Fair PriceFair price — $1,211 (0%) above the $373,789 fair price, lower mileage than 74% of 46 comparable listings.$1,211 over | 2012 | Coupe | 16,000 mi | No accidents (Autotrader badge) | Exotic Car Trader | — | Autotrader | View | |||
$377,244NEW Fair PriceFair price — $5,037 (1%) above the $372,207 fair price, lower mileage than 66% of 46 comparable listings.$5,037 over | 2013 | Coupe | 17,000 mi | History not shown - CHECK CARFAX | Dealer Fees Included | — | Autotrader | View | |||
$379,950NEW Fair PriceFair price — $10,316 (3%) above the $369,634 fair price, lower mileage than 58% of 46 comparable listings.$10,316 over | 2012 | Coupe | 18,000 mi | No accidents (Autotrader badge) | Land Rover Van Nuys | — | Autotrader | View | |||
$379,995NEW Fair PriceFair price — $10,715 (3%) above the $369,280 fair price, lower mileage than 58% of 46 comparable listings.$10,715 over | 2015 | Coupe | 18,000 mi | No accidents (Autotrader badge) | SR Auto Group | — | Autotrader | View | |||
$380,412NEW OverpricedOverpriced — $18,599 (5%) above the $361,813 fair price for 46 comparable listings.$18,599 over | 2012 | Coupe | 24,000 mi | History not shown - CHECK CARFAX | Dealer Fees Included | — | Autotrader | View | |||
$380,890NEW Fair PriceFair price — $5,830 (2%) above the $375,060 fair price, lower mileage than 66% of 46 comparable listings.$5,830 over | 2011 | Coupe | 17,000 mi | History not shown - CHECK CARFAX | Dealer Fees Included | — | Autotrader | View | |||
$382,995NEW OverpricedOverpriced — $14,269 (4%) above the $368,726 fair price, lower mileage than 52% of 46 comparable listings.$14,269 over | 2013 | Coupe | 19,000 mi | History not shown - CHECK CARFAX | Dealer Fees Included | — | Autotrader | View | |||
$384,995NEW Fair PriceFair price — $12,394 (3%) above the $372,601 fair price, lower mileage than 76% of 46 comparable listings.$12,394 over | 2013 | Coupe | 15,000 mi | No accidents (Autotrader badge) | The Car House Of Wayne LLC | — | Autotrader | View | |||
$389,000NEW HighPriced high — $22,552 (6%) above the $366,448 fair price, lower mileage than 66% of 46 comparable listings.$22,552 over | 2011 | Coupe | 17,000 mi | No accidents (Autotrader badge) | Sponsored by Private Seller Exchange | Oviedo, FL | Autotrader | View | |||
$389,099NEW HighPriced high — $14,990 (4%) above the $374,109 fair price, lower mileage than 87% of 46 comparable listings.$14,990 over | 2010 | Coupe | 7,000 mi | History not shown - CHECK CARFAX | Dealer Fees Included | Salt Lake City, UT | Autotrader | View | |||
 | HighPriced high — $58,149 (16%) above the $370,417 fair price, lower mileage than 67% of 3 comparable listings. (Few comparables — lower confidence.)$58,149 over | 2013 | 458 Italia | 11,276 mi | History not shown - CHECK CARFAX (CPO) | Wide World Ferrari | Spring Valley, NY | Cars.com | View | ||
 | HighPriced high — $40,139 (10%) above the $389,860 fair price, lower mileage than 83% of 46 comparable listings.$40,139 over | 2011 | Base | 7,875 mi | History not shown - CHECK CARFAX | Continental Ferrari | Hinsdale, IL | Cars.com | View | ||
 | HighPriced high — $56,382 (15%) above the $379,066 fair price, lower mileage than 78% of 46 comparable listings.$56,382 over | 2012 | Base | 12,667 mi | History not shown - CHECK CARFAX | Maserati of Cleveland | Cleveland, OH | Cars.com | View | ||
$465,412NEW OverpricedOverpriced — $86,137 (23%) above the $379,275 fair price, lower mileage than 87% of 46 comparable listings.$86,137 over | 2011 | Coupe | 7,000 mi | History not shown - CHECK CARFAX | Dealer Fees Included | Hinsdale, IL | Autotrader | View | |||
 | OverpricedOverpriced — $96,535 (26%) above the $373,365 fair price, lower mileage than 72% of 46 comparable listings.$96,535 over | 2012 | Base | 16,216 mi | History not shown - CHECK CARFAX | Young Motorcars | Scottsdale, AZ | Cars.com | View | ||
 | OverpricedOverpriced — $110,902 (29%) above the $379,782 fair price, lower mileage than 80% of 46 comparable listings.$110,902 over | 2015 | Base | 9,435 mi | History not shown - CHECK CARFAX | Ferrari of Boca Raton | Boca Raton, FL | Cars.com | View | ||
 | 2011 | Base | 17,500 mi | History not shown - CHECK CARFAX | Luxury Auto Collection | Scottsdale, AZ | Cars.com | View | |||
| 2010 | Base | 17,000 mi | History not shown - CHECK CARFAX | Private seller: Tom | Irvine, CA | Cars.com | View | |||
 | OverpricedOverpriced — $105,845 (27%) above the $394,150 fair price, lower mileage than 96% of 46 comparable listings.$105,845 over | 2015 | Base | 4,365 mi | History not shown - CHECK CARFAX | Ryan Friedman Motor Cars | Glen Cove, NY | Cars.com | View | ||
 | OverpricedOverpriced — $111,229 (29%) above the $388,766 fair price, lower mileage than 91% of 46 comparable listings.$111,229 over | 2014 | Base | 6,553 mi | History not shown - CHECK CARFAX | Gulf Coast Motorworks | Bonita Springs, FL | Cars.com | View | ||
 | OverpricedOverpriced — $111,361 (29%) above the $388,714 fair price, lower mileage than 98% of 46 comparable listings.$111,361 over | 2014 | Base | 3,925 mi | History not shown - CHECK CARFAX | Ferrari Silicon Valley | Redwood City, CA | Cars.com | View | ||
 | OverpricedOverpriced — $111,520 (29%) above the $388,928 fair price, lower mileage than 93% of 46 comparable listings.$111,520 over | 2011 | Base | 5,100 mi | History not shown - CHECK CARFAX | Maserati of Cleveland | Cleveland, OH | Cars.com | View |
Highlighted rows = accident history not shown by the listing; confirm via CARFAX before purchase. CarGurus prices may include dealer fees, so a duplicate car is priced from Cars.com / Autotrader where available.
Market price trend
as of 2026-08-27$366K▲ 11.0% over 7 wks
How the Ferrari 458 Italia market moves
modeled from 50 live listings−$44K/10k mivalue cost of every 10,000 miles
$366Ktypical asking today
Trend forecast: ≈ −$44K over the next 12 months · at ~10k mi/yr, depreciation only — excludes market swings
Market: Supercar asking prices are down 1.0% over the last 9 weeks, holding model, mileage and age constant. · a separate signal from depreciation, not added to it