All models

Subaru Legacy

Nationwide US · 59 listings · 4 great deals · updated 2026-08-26
Under $22K
49 cars
Cheapest
$7,490
Average
$14,289
Great deals
4
Verify CARFAX
59 flagged

Deal breakdown

46 priced vs. fair value · click to filter · how?
Great Deal 4Good Deal 15Fair Price 14High 9Overpriced 4
Median price $15,000Median miles 67,667
★ Best deal right now
$11,900
2019 Limited · 62,498 mi
$4,448 under fair value (fair $16,348)
Fair range $11,704–$20,763 · vs 13 comparable listings
Cheaper than 85% of comparable listings

Price vs. mileage

each dot is a listing · line = market trend · dots below the line are better value
$6K$13K$20K$27K$34K025k50k75k100kMileage2019 Premium — $7,490 · 79,683 mi2019 2.5i Limited — $8,500 · 90,000 mi2018 2.5i Premium — $9,950 · 93,000 mi · Good Deal2018 2.5i Premium — $10,950 · 77,000 mi · Good Deal2018 2.5i Sport — $10,990 · 82,000 mi · Great Deal2018 2.5i — $10,995 · 74,000 mi · Great Deal2018 Limited — $11,000 · 42,360 mi2018 2.5i Premium — $11,251 · 45,000 mi · Good Deal2019 2.5i Limited — $11,900 · 62,000 mi · Fair Price2019 Limited — $11,900 · 62,498 mi · Good Deal2019 2.5i Premium — $12,251 · 68,000 mi · Fair Price2018 2.5i Premium — $12,499 · 97,000 mi · Fair Price2020 Premium — $12,499 · 56,884 mi · Good Deal2020 Premium — $12,799 · 56,000 mi · Great Deal2018 Premium — $12,953 · 74,481 mi · Great Deal2018 2.5i Sport — $12,995 · 69,000 mi · Good Deal2019 Sport — $12,995 · 66,595 mi · Good Deal2018 Premium — $13,400 · 99,856 mi · Good Deal2018 Base — $13,450 · 59,232 mi · Fair Price2018 2.5i Premium — $13,488 · 44,000 mi · High2019 2.5i — $13,500 · 82,000 mi · Fair Price2022 Premium — $13,950 · 52,000 mi · Good Deal2022 Premium — $13,999 · 38,000 mi · Good Deal2021 Premium — $14,294 · 95,000 mi · Good Deal2019 2.5i Sport — $14,295 · 98,000 mi · Fair Price2019 Base — $14,888 · 98,920 mi · Fair Price2025 Base — $14,998 · 29,748 mi2018 Premium — $14,999 · 70,126 mi · Fair Price2019 2.5i Premium — $15,000 · 95,674 mi · Overpriced2022 Limited — $15,000 · 71,677 mi · Good Deal2019 2.5i — $15,875 · 79,710 mi · High2018 Premium — $15,995 · 62,416 mi · Fair Price2019 Premium — $15,995 · 67,667 mi · Fair Price2021 Premium — $15,995 · 79,465 mi · Fair Price2022 Premium — $15,995 · 61,509 mi · Fair Price2019 2.5i — $16,422 · 74,968 mi · High2022 Limited — $16,499 · 90,755 mi · Good Deal2018 Base — $16,500 · 61,502 mi · High2024 Premium — $16,500 · 42,000 mi · Good Deal2023 Premium — $16,990 · 34,903 mi · Good Deal2020 Premium — $17,238 · 72,182 mi · High2019 Limited — $17,246 · 88,462 mi · Fair Price2019 Premium — $17,334 · 82,516 mi · High2018 Limited — $17,398 · 73,524 mi · High2021 Limited — $17,399 · 89,119 mi · High2020 Limited — $17,446 · 96,794 mi · High2019 2.5i Premium — $17,489 · 63,405 mi2022 Limited — $17,490 · 10,815 mi · Fair Price2021 Limited — $19,200 · 77,000 mi · Overpriced2022 Premium — $22,199 · 45,000 mi2025 Premium — $23,500 · 16,000 mi · Overpriced2024 Premium — $25,097 · 40,000 mi2025 Premium — $26,350 · 12,000 mi2025 Premium — $26,771 · 8,000 mi2025 Premium — $27,444 · 11,000 mi2024 Touring XT — $30,498 · 27,000 mi · Overpriced2025 Limited — $31,768 · 15,000 mi2025 Limited — $32,068 · 6,000 mi2025 Limited — $32,316 · 5,000 mi
CompareExport Excel49 cars
–
–
Trim
Source
Deal
Price▲YearTrimBodyMileageAccident / Title HistoryDealerLocationSource
2019 Premium
$7,490
2019Premium79,683 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXIauto.usDallas, TXCars.comView
$8,500NEW
20192.5i Limited90,000 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXBetancourt Auto SalesMiami, FLAutotraderView
$9,950
Good deal — $2,770 (22%) below the $12,720 fair price, cheaper than 88% of 8 comparable listings.$2,770 under
20182.5i Premium93,000 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXInterstate Auto Center, IncHarrisburg, SDAutotraderView
$10,950NEW
Good deal — $1,788 (14%) below the $12,738 fair price, cheaper than 75% of 8 comparable listings.$1,788 under
20182.5i Premium77,000 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXInterstate Auto Center, IncHarrisburg, SDAutotraderView
$10,990
Great deal — $3,356 (23%) below the $14,346 fair price, cheaper than 67% of 3 comparable listings. (Few comparables — lower confidence.)$3,356 under
20182.5i Sport82,000 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXMotor Mesh Automotive, LLC.Colorado Springs, COAutotraderView
$10,995
↓ $1,000 this week
Great deal — $3,178 (22%) below the $14,173 fair price, cheaper than 75% and lower mileage than 75% of 4 comparable listings. (Few comparables — lower confidence.)$3,178 under
20182.5i74,000 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXDealerAttleboro, MAAutotraderView
2018 Limited
$11,000
2018Limited42,360 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAX (CPO)Speed Auto SalesPittsburgh, PACars.comView
$11,251NEW
Good deal — $1,073 (9%) below the $12,324 fair price, cheaper than 62% and lower mileage than 75% of 8 comparable listings.$1,073 under
20182.5i Premium45,000 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXIncredible Auto Sales LLCBountiful, UTAutotraderView
$11,900
Fair price — $321 (3%) below the $12,221 fair price, lower mileage than 50% of 2 comparable listings. (Few comparables — lower confidence.)
20192.5i Limited62,000 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXSell Your Auto FastOrlando, FLAutotraderView
2019 Limited
$11,900
Good deal — $4,448 (27%) below the $16,348 fair price, cheaper than 85% and lower mileage than 54% of 13 comparable listings.$4,448 under
2019Limited62,498 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAX (CPO)Sell Your Auto FastOrlando, FLCars.comView
$12,251NEW
Fair price — priced right around the $12,072 fair-price estimate, cheaper than 50% and lower mileage than 50% of 8 comparable listings.
20192.5i Premium68,000 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXIncredible Auto Sales LLCBountiful, UTAutotraderView
$12,499
↓ $1,981 this week
Fair price — priced right around the $12,520 fair-price estimate for 8 comparable listings.
20182.5i Premium97,000 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXDealer Fees IncludedLa Crescent, MNAutotraderView
2020 Premium
$12,499
Good deal — $2,844 (19%) below the $15,343 fair price, cheaper than 91% of 23 comparable listings.$2,844 under
2020Premium56,884 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXSmart Motors Inc.Houston, TXCars.comView
$12,799
Great deal — $2,687 (17%) below the $15,486 fair price, cheaper than 87% and lower mileage than 52% of 23 comparable listings.$2,687 under
2020Premium56,000 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXSmart Motors Inc.—AutotraderView
2018 Premium
$12,953
Great deal — $2,248 (15%) below the $15,201 fair price, cheaper than 83% of 23 comparable listings.$2,248 under
2018Premium74,481 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXHigh Demand—Cars.comView
$12,995NEW
Good deal — $1,269 (9%) below the $14,264 fair price, lower mileage than 67% of 3 comparable listings. (Few comparables — lower confidence.)$1,269 under
20182.5i Sport69,000 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXNorth South Motorcars—AutotraderView
2019 Sport
$12,995
Good deal — $1,321 (9%) below the $14,316 fair price for 1 comparable listing. (Few comparables — lower confidence.)$1,321 under
2019Sport66,595 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXCapital Auto FinanceBridgeview, ILCars.comView
2018 Premium
$13,400
Good deal — $1,644 (11%) below the $15,044 fair price, cheaper than 78% of 23 comparable listings.$1,644 under
2018Premium99,856 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAX (CPO)Alexander NissanMuncy, PACars.comView
2018 Base
$13,450
Fair price — priced right around the $13,423 fair-price estimate, cheaper than 75% and lower mileage than 50% of 4 comparable listings. (Few comparables — lower confidence.)
2018Base59,232 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXPremium Spec Auto—Cars.comView
$13,488
Priced high — $610 (5%) above the $12,878 fair price, lower mileage than 88% of 8 comparable listings.
20182.5i Premium44,000 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXDealer—AutotraderView
$13,500NEW
Fair price — $430 (3%) below the $13,930 fair price, cheaper than 50% of 4 comparable listings. (Few comparables — lower confidence.)
20192.5i82,000 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXAUTO TIME—AutotraderView
$13,950
Good deal — $2,563 (16%) below the $16,513 fair price, cheaper than 74% and lower mileage than 57% of 23 comparable listings.$2,563 under
2022Premium52,000 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXDealer Fees Included—AutotraderView
$13,999NEW
Good deal — $2,772 (17%) below the $16,771 fair price, cheaper than 70% and lower mileage than 74% of 23 comparable listings.$2,772 under
2022Premium38,000 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXMurphy Motors, Inc.—AutotraderView
$14,294NEW
Good deal — $994 (7%) below the $15,288 fair price, cheaper than 65% of 23 comparable listings.$994 under
2021Premium95,000 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXDealer Fees Included—AutotraderView
$14,295NEW
Fair price — $483 (3%) above the $13,812 fair price for 3 comparable listings. (Few comparables — lower confidence.)
20192.5i Sport98,000 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXGood Price—AutotraderView
2019 Base
$14,888
Fair price — $452 (3%) below the $15,340 fair price, cheaper than 50% of 4 comparable listings. (Few comparables — lower confidence.)
2019Base98,920 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXAt Your Service Auto Sales and AccessoriesVersailles, MOCars.comView
2025 Base
$14,998
2025Base29,748 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXUB Automotive LLCEnglewood, COCars.comView
2018 Premium
$14,999
Fair price — priced right around the $15,119 fair-price estimate, cheaper than 61% of 23 comparable listings.
2018Premium70,126 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXAKOI MotorsPhoenix, AZCars.comView
2019 2.5i Premium
$15,000
Overpriced — $2,312 (18%) above the $12,688 fair price for 8 comparable listings.$2,312 over
20192.5i Premium95,674 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXMaguire Chevrolet of Grand IslandGrand Island, NYCars.comView
2022 Limited
$15,000
Good deal — $2,820 (16%) below the $17,820 fair price, cheaper than 77% of 13 comparable listings.$2,820 under
2022Limited71,677 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXBaba's Motorsports LLCPhoenix, AZCars.comView
2019 2.5i
$15,875
Priced high — $2,612 (20%) above the $13,263 fair price for 4 comparable listings. (Few comparables — lower confidence.)$2,612 over
20192.5i79,710 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXSubaru of Pembroke PinesPembroke Pines, FLCars.comView
2018 Premium
$15,995
Fair price — $468 (3%) above the $15,527 fair price, cheaper than 50% of 23 comparable listings.
2018Premium62,416 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXBoss AutoAppleton, WICars.comView
2019 Premium
$15,995
Fair price — $487 (3%) above the $15,508 fair price, cheaper than 50% of 23 comparable listings.
2019Premium67,667 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXAli Luxury MotorsGlenview, ILCars.comView
2021 Premium
$15,995
Fair price — $512 (3%) above the $15,483 fair price, cheaper than 50% of 23 comparable listings.
2021Premium79,465 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXAM Motors LLCBellevue, NECars.comView
2022 Premium
$15,995
Fair price — priced right around the $16,047 fair-price estimate, cheaper than 50% of 23 comparable listings.
2022Premium61,509 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXBob's Auto RanchLino Lakes, MNCars.comView
2019 2.5i
$16,422
Priced high — $2,334 (17%) above the $14,088 fair price, lower mileage than 50% of 4 comparable listings. (Few comparables — lower confidence.)$2,334 over
20192.5i74,968 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXNapoli Auto XpressMilford, CTCars.comView
2022 Limited
$16,499
Good deal — $1,379 (8%) below the $17,878 fair price, cheaper than 69% of 13 comparable listings.$1,379 under
2022Limited90,755 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXCarface Auto SalesParma, OHCars.comView
2018 Base
$16,500
Priced high — $2,898 (21%) above the $13,602 fair price for 4 comparable listings. (Few comparables — lower confidence.)$2,898 over
2018Base61,502 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXAutoNation Subaru WestGolden, COCars.comView
2024 Premium
$16,500
Good deal — $1,912 (10%) below the $18,412 fair price, lower mileage than 65% of 23 comparable listings.$1,912 under
2024Premium42,000 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXPrivate seller: Maks Auto LlcChariton, IACars.comView
2023 Premium
$16,990
Good deal — $845 (5%) below the $17,835 fair price, lower mileage than 78% of 23 comparable listings.$845 under
2023Premium34,903 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXOptimus Auto LLCOmaha, NECars.comView
2020 Premium
$17,238
Priced high — $1,824 (12%) above the $15,414 fair price for 23 comparable listings.$1,824 over
2020Premium72,182 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXRed Rock NissanGrand Junction, COCars.comView
2019 Limited
$17,246
Fair price — $488 (3%) above the $16,758 fair price, cheaper than 62% of 13 comparable listings.
2019Limited88,462 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXGreg's Automotive LLCMishawaka, INCars.comView
2019 Premium
$17,334
Priced high — $2,201 (15%) above the $15,133 fair price for 23 comparable listings.$2,201 over
2019Premium82,516 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXBattaglia Auto Sales RetailPlymouth Meeting, PACars.comView
2018 Limited
$17,398
Priced high — $909 (6%) above the $16,489 fair price, cheaper than 54% of 13 comparable listings.$909 over
2018Limited73,524 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXSkye Auto Haus, LLCWeaverville, NCCars.comView
2021 Limited
$17,399
Priced high — $965 (6%) above the $16,434 fair price for 13 comparable listings.$965 over
2021Limited89,119 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXAuto HousePhoenix, AZCars.comView
2020 Limited
$17,446
Priced high — $595 (4%) above the $16,851 fair price for 13 comparable listings.
2020Limited96,794 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXTeam Chevrolet of SwansboroSwansboro, NCCars.comView
2019 2.5i Premium
$17,489
20192.5i Premium63,405 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXHigh Demand—Cars.comView
2022 Limited
$17,490
Fair price — $299 (2%) above the $17,191 fair price, lower mileage than 77% of 13 comparable listings.
2022Limited10,815 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXAutolocity MotorsOgden, UTCars.comView
$19,200NEW
Overpriced — $2,387 (14%) above the $16,813 fair price for 13 comparable listings.$2,387 over
2021Limited77,000 miHistory not shown - CHECK CARFAXGreat PriceBoise, IDAutotraderView

Highlighted rows = accident history not shown by the listing; confirm via CARFAX before purchase. CarGurus prices may include dealer fees, so a duplicate car is priced from Cars.com / Autotrader where available.

How the Subaru Legacy market moves

modeled from 59 live listings
−8.5%/yrlost to age, miles held equal
−$191/10k mivalue cost of every 10,000 miles
$15Ktypical asking today
Estimated value vs. mileage · higher-mileage cars sit lower on the curve

Trend forecast: ≈ −$1K over the next 12 months · at ~10k mi/yr, depreciation only — excludes market swings

Market: the tracked market asking prices are up 2.4% over the last 12 weeks, holding model, mileage and age constant. · a separate signal from depreciation, not added to it

What each trim is worth · vs. Premium, same age & miles
  • Premium23baseline
  • Limited13+$2K